TrustBridge Regulatory Database

Regulatory scorecards

How regulators' orders fare on appeal, built from the orders in TrustBridge's Regulatory Database. Updated every quarter.

ERC Appellate Performance Scorecard

Appeals against MERC and CERC orders decided by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, by quarter of the APTEL decision.

Latest: Q2 FY 2026–27 · 2 quarters of data

  • AllowedERC order was overturned or modified
  • DismissedERC order was upheld
  • Partially allowedERC order was partially overturned
  • Otherwise disposed ofProceedings closed with directions or observations
  • RemandedERC directed to re-consider a decision
Q1 FY 2026–27
Apr–Jun 2026
Q2 FY 2026–27
Jul–Sep 2026
All periods
Q1 FY 2026–27 – Q2 FY 2026–27
  • Each pair of columns is one commission: its appeals by outcome, and beside them the remanded appeals. Remanded appeals are also counted as allowed or partially allowed, so they are shown next to the stack, not in it.
  • Counts are per appeal, in the quarter APTEL decided it; one judgment can decide several appeals. "All periods" adds up every quarter to date and has its own scale.
Show these numbers as a table
PeriodCommissionAllowedDismissedPartially allowedOtherwise disposed ofAppeals decidedRemanded
Q1 FY 2026–27MERC520070
Q1 FY 2026–27CERC430072
Q2 FY 2026–27MERC501065
Q2 FY 2026–27CERC342095
All periodsMERC10210135
All periodsCERC7720167

At a glance: Q2 FY 2026–27 compared with Q1 FY 2026–27

MERCMaharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission
Appeals decided
6−1
Dismissed
0.0%−28.6 pts
Allowed
83.3%+11.9 pts
Remanded
83.3%+83.3 pts
CERCCentral Electricity Regulatory Commission
Appeals decided
9+2
Dismissed
44.4%+1.5 pts
Allowed
33.3%−23.8 pts
Remanded
55.6%+27.0 pts